"All the seating out there, except for those seats at the bar, are for anybody. There is no obligation. If you want to sit at a table, you can. You don't have to buy anything." That was Mayor Mark Short describing the T-end of the Anna Maria City Pier to the Anna Maria Island Sun in June, after commissioners approved the pier's new lease.
That rule matters most to the people who walk Pine Avenue all year. Pine Avenue runs from the Gulf beach to the City Pier. Since the 2024 hurricanes took out the walkway, the street has stopped at the water. Once the pier is open again, the walk ends on a covered platform over the bay with public tables, a bar, bait and tackle, and fishing. The schedule says the T-end opens at 7 a.m. and closes at 10 p.m., seven days a week.
One Tenant, Both Buildings, and Tables for Anyone
On June 11, city commissioners voted unanimously for a five-year lease with GSM Partners LLC, whose partners are Brian Seymour, Ben Sato and Jason Sato. Their business on the T-end is called PIERadise, and it is planned as open-air. GSM Partners pays the city $12,000 a month and covers ongoing maintenance on the space it leases. Rent rises each year with the Consumer Price Index, capped at 3% a year, and the lease has an option for a second five-year term.
The T-end is laid out differently from before. The former City Pier Grill ran out of the smaller of the two T-end buildings. PIERadise takes both. Seymour told the Sun the menu would change from City Pier Grill's but stay family-friendly and affordable. Breakfast, lunch and dinner menus are in the works, with beer and wine, and bait and tackle are coming back. In October, Seymour gave The Anna Maria Islander a fuller preview of a "pier-focused" menu with burgers, fish tacos and sandwiches, ceviche and bowls. Under the lease, the pier's common areas and the business are open seven days a week, 7 a.m. to 10 p.m.
Before PIERadise and before City Pier Grill, Mario Schoenfelder ran the pier. He had the City Pier Restaurant in the larger building and a bait shop with a draft-beer bar in the smaller one, until Hurricane Irma closed the old pier in 2017. The new plan brings back bait and tackle and adds a covered bar and dining area. Short's rule about the tables adds something the old setup didn't spell out: a T-end that works like a public porch for anyone who walks out.
Built on Different Legs Than the 2020 Pier
The pier being finished now is the second rebuild in six years. After Irma, the city spent $6.8 million on a new walkway and the T-end buildings, which opened in 2020. The 2024 hurricanes destroyed that walkway. The T-end buildings, set on solid concrete pilings, stayed standing.
The difference is under the walkway. The 2020 walkway had composite decking on a wooden frame, set on hollow spun-concrete pilings. The new walkway, built by Tampa Bay Marine under a $4.64 million base contract, sits on solid concrete pilings, the same kind that carried the T-end through the storms.
Estimates for the whole project grew over the course of the work. In October 2025 the Sun reported a total of $6.2 million to $6.9 million. By March 2026, the mayor's estimate was $7.1 million to $7.8 million. That figure included $700,000 to $900,000 for the T-end buildings, restrooms and lighting, and $500,000 to $600,000 for utility lines. Committed public funding came to $6.84 million: $1.25 million from the state, up to $2 million from Manatee County and $3.6 million from FEMA. The city covers the rest.
Where the Work Stood Going Into the Holidays
Through the spring, the work moved from the walkway out to the T-end. By mid-May the last walkway slab was in, utility work was underway and decking was next. The plan was to finish the walkway first so crews could reach the T-end buildings for repairs and remediation.
In the fall, work moved inside. The Islander reported on Oct. 27 that work was continuing inside the pier building, while wind and tides were holding up the remaining work under the platform. On Nov. 3 it reported two contractor teams working on electrical and water lines, ahead of schedule on the utility milestones, with indoor work focused on electrical, plumbing and a fire-sprinkler system. In June, the Sun reported the pier was expected to reopen in November, with PIERadise opening at or soon after the reopening. In late October, Seymour told The Islander he was aiming for early December, or November if luck and weather held.
If you're planning a December evening around the pier, check the City of Anna Maria website the week you go.
December 11 Is the Fixed Date
The City of Anna Maria calendar lists the Holiday Walk for Friday, Dec. 11, 2026, from 5 to 9 p.m.
Last year's walk was on Friday, Dec. 12, 2025, along Pine Avenue. Anna Maria's businesses, the City of Anna Maria and the Anna Maria Island Historical Society hosted it. Santa was at the museum, and the city lit its tree at 6 p.m. The Sun's coverage of the 2025 Holiday of Treasures open house listed the businesses that took part: Beach Bums, Pineapple Marketplace, Anna Maria General Store, Two Scoops, Cool Beans, Pizza Social, Flip Flop Shop & Candy Stop, Chocolate Emporium and Donut Experiment. That gives a good picture of what the street looks like on the night, even if this year's list changes.
The Anna Maria Island Historical Society Museum, at 402 Pine Ave., has been the center of the walk. Outside of the walk, the museum is open Tuesday through Saturday, 10 a.m. to 1 p.m., April through December, and closed Sundays and Mondays. A December weekday morning there is quieter than the night of the walk. Roser Memorial Community Church is a few doors along the same stretch. Farther up the street, Poppo's Taqueria is at 212C Pine Ave. and lists daily hours of 11 a.m. to 9 p.m., which covers the whole walk.
The 2024 hurricanes cancelled that year's open house along with other annual events. When it came back in 2025, the Sun's year in review listed it among the events that returned, and that night Pine Avenue still ended at a closed pier. If PIERadise is open by Dec. 11, the walk ends on the bay at a T-end built for crowds, with tables open to anyone and room to stand at the rail after the tree lighting.
Getting to Pine Avenue in December
Parking on Pine Avenue is still free. In August, a consultant's parking study suggested a mix of resident permits, paid parking and time limits. One idea in it was 52 business spaces on Pine Avenue with a three-hour limit. City commissioners and the planning board took it up together on Oct. 27. According to the Sun's Nov. 5 report, they made no decisions or commitments. The plan under discussion includes resident permits, free time-limited parking near businesses, employee spaces and paid parking near some beach accesses. The mayor's revised estimate was $400,000 to $600,000 a year in parking revenue. He hoped for a March 1 start but wasn't sure the city could make it. For the Holiday Walk this December, Pine Avenue parking is free.
On walk night, when spaces fill early, the free island trolley is the other way to get there. It runs to the City Pier at the north end of the island.
The Pier's Next Chapter Is a Ferry
PIERadise is the first part of the pier's return. Short told the Sun that the public T-end seating will also serve Gulf Islands Ferry passengers when ferry service comes back to the City Pier, which he expects in 2027 or 2028. That's when the end of Pine Avenue becomes an arrival point for people who come by water. Until then, the open tables are mostly for the people who walk out from town.
For more on where islanders have been eating in the meantime, see our earlier post, Anna Maria Island Never Waited for Beach Bistro to Reopen. For a broader look at the city, see our Anna Maria neighborhood page.
If you own a home a short walk from Pine Avenue and want to know how a reopened City Pier and the city's parking decision may affect what buyers ask about your street, Louis Acevedo can walk you through it. Schedule a Call and we'll look at it together.